Hello Dolly
Overall rating:

The Internet Movie Database       Movie Reviews
     
 
What's Otter's
rating system?
From the play The Matchmaker by Thornton Wilder

A celebrated matchmaker is out to make a match for herself.

This one is a bundle of contradictions...kind of hard to categorize...but there are many good and bad things about it:

  • Good: It's a very funny script, full of good sight gags and funny lines.
  • Bad: Many of the actors have no clue how to deliver these lines.
  • Good: The plot is intricate, but it all works out in the end.
  • Bad: The ending (Walter Matthau suddenly, after vehemently denying any feelings for Streisand, softens up and proposes to her in the last 5 minutes of the movie)
  • Good: The costumes: big, bright, bold
  • Bad: The costumes: overwhelming and tacky
  • Good: Half of the musical numbers are great! Wonderful tunes, big dance sequences, color, movement, very nice.
  • Bad: Many of the songs (especially the tender introspective ones) are just awful if not downright embarrassing
  • Good: Barbara Streisand.
  • Bad: Barbara Streisand
  • Good: Walter Matthau playing (as he does so well) a woman hating curmudgeon
  • Bad: Walter Matthau trying to sing. Oh god.
Well, anyway. You get the idea. If you love musicals, and don't hate Barbara Streisand's incredibly overblown and annoying persona, which can also be endearingly funny and sweet, this is worth a watch. Have a book or a fellow musical maven nearby so that you have someone to talk to when the plot slows down or one of the really awful numbers pops up...but you'll be singin' and dancin' during the good parts.